5 lbs white wheat malt
2 lbs popcorn
3/4 gallon pineapple juice
4 lbs clover honey
3 lbs 1 oz mango puree
1 oz hops in boil (galaxy)
1 oz dry hops (galaxy)
15g Laffort Zymaflore X5 yeast
Serving option of chamoy and tajin (for pepper)
Pre-honey OG was 1.017
Honey brought OG up to 1.061
FG 1.000
ABV ~8.98%
12.5g GoFerm
18.03g DAP
9.46g Fermaid K
Coarsely grind popcorn with coffee grinder and place in pot
Pour pineapple juice over popcorn until ground kernels are covered
Allow to soak. You can use iodine to check when the starches are converted to sugar - mine took about 2 hours.
Iodine + starch will be blue-black (enzyme rest needs more time)
Iodine + sugar will be orange-brown (enzyme rest is complete)
Heat 2.25 gallons water to 154F
Grains in and flame out
Mash for 70 min
Boil for 72 min
1 oz hops 60 min into boil
This is a good time to prepare GoFerm and rehydrate yeast per package instructions
Cool wort down towards a more pitchable temperature
Add mango puree and water up to 3 gal (chilling these ingredients in advance can help bring wort temperature down faster)
Check gravity
Add honey and water to desired gravity/volume targets. Don't forget to account for the volume of honey itself if calculating target OG.
At my extraction efficiency, 4 lbs honey was needed to hit a good gravity, and it brought me up to 3.25 gallons primary volume (a good target to start with if you're aiming for 3 gal secondary volume).
When wort is at a pitchable temperature, add GoFerm solution
Add 1 oz hops
Seal up bucket and ferment!
Add nutrients per your preferred schedule.
This brew is part of a big collaboration with many of the other brewtube channels on YouTube!
It's my... second (I think?) attempt at brew-in-a-bag, and clearly, I have some holes in my process still. I ruin one batch entirely, and even in the batch that I actually do end up using that went well, it's clear I got very little gravity out of my mash process. The braggot ended up fermenting dry, which is unusual - I expected the grains to leave some unfermentable gravity behind, but they didn't, which I assume indicates a problem with my mash extraction.
All-in-all, though, it was a fun challenge and I learned a lot!
07/08/2021 - pitched initial test batch
This was a test batch to see if I could use my desired star ingredient - malted popcorn - as 1) a grain in a mash and 2) a source of fermentable sugar. I made up a test batch using just the malted popcorn so I could see what effect it had on gravity after a mash, but it didn't give me almost any sugar at all. I figured I would have to rely on other sources for my fermentables in the main batch, but decided to add table sugar to this one so that it could still ferment and I could test flavor when it was done (and make sure that malted popcorn isn't disgusting or anything).
07/10/2021 - testing the initial test batch
The small batch was pretty low gravity and only needed a couple days to ferment out. It mostly tastes like a hopped sugar wash. Which is actually a decent result - at least I know the malted popcorn and process I'm trying to implement here doesn't create horrible off-flavors. But I'll have to crank the settings up a bit if I want to get any flavor out of this.
07/13/2021 - pitch batch 2
If this works, it could be the actual batch. But as a newbie to brew-in-a-bag, I didn't realize I had to flame out when I added the bag, and promptly burned/melted it. I clearly still have a lot to learn!
Anyway - I can already tell this has some campfire smoke flavors and aromas going on. I'm not sure yet if that'll be workable. I am considering starting another batch, but I may wait until this has developed a little further to see if I can learn anything else from this batch before restarting.
08/26/2021 - pitch batch 3
Batch 2 definitely had too much burned flavor from the bag-burn incident. I took it to completion and bottled some to test my idea of using the mango smoothie mixture as priming sugar and pasteurizing... didn't like the result though. It didn't carbonate well, and the mango addition was so thick it didn't taste alike a remotely alcoholic beverage, let alone a beer. The beverage just tasted like badly torched mango.
So after another round of attempting to malt popcorn, I was ready to try again with some modifications. But this time the malted popcorn smelled off. I think it may have molded or something like that. Rather than risk it, I followed the important advice to never save moldy homebrew and tossed it out.
Unfortunately, I was running out of time to hit the original project deadline, and didn't have weeks to spent malting another round of popcorn. So instead, I tried soaking coarsely ground popcorn (unmalted) in pineapple juice - the idea being, the bromelain in the pineapple juice would break the popcorn starch down into fermentable sugars. And this time around, since I was too close to the deadline for another test batch, I verified the conversion of starch to sugars using iodine - which turns dark blue or black in the presence of starches.
Boiling the corn should also work as a starch conversion method, but I wanted to do something that allowed me to at least kind of verify I had gotten fermentable sugar out of the corn before the mash, as at that point, it would no longer be isolated from other ingredients for testing - and my initial test batch relied on a boil, yet yielded no fermentable sugars. I probably did something wrong with that mash, but since I hadn't figured it out yet, I wasn't inclined to rely on it working correctly this time.
After about 2 hours soaking in pineapple juice, the iodine I added to a sample already appeared brown-orange, so as best I could tell, we had sugar! I dumped that pineapple-corn mixture into the brew bag along with the wheat when it was time for the mash and went from there.
Because the mango puree in secondary didn't work very well on the previous test batch, I decided to dump the mango puree directly into primary this time around.
09/02/2021 - racked
Already dry at 1.000. Smells very hoppy, might have overdone the hops - and it has a weird cap formed out of what I assume is some combination of wheat and corn gunk at the top.
All the more reason to rack it now. I don't mind if it ferments a couple extra points in the carboy at this point, and I think it's worth getting it off both the hops and that weird gunk cap at the top (it's not mold, it might be congealed fruit solids from the mango).
Not gunna bother taste-testing it just yet, what I racked is super hazy and needs some time to clear up. I shoved the carboy into the back of a shelf to limit UV exposure since it's hopped.
10/01/2021 - filtered & bottled
This poor braggot wasn't clearing very quickly, and from all the time I spent trying to get malted popcorn to work, I was running out of time to hit our group's initial deadline. So I decided to put this through a rough filter pass - and only the rough pass, because it's going to be bottle-carbonated so it won't be crystal clear anyway - before bottling. After that, I bottled
11/10/2021 - initial tasting
This came out pretty fantastic. It tastes like a wheat-based tropical braggot, but the popcorn is present! This style of wheat is a tad thin for my personal preferences, but similar beers all taste like that to me, so I do think I nailed the style.
I'm cheating a little bit on the last ingredient - pepper - in the name of entertainment. The pepper wasn't directly added, but instead, is included in the intended serving method - a pint glass where the rim is salted with tajin. Why, you ask?
Well, there's a beverage called a mangonada, which is itself delicious and combines mangoes with tajin and chamoy. But beyond that, some places serve beers in a way that's rather mangonada-inspired - for example, I've been to one restaurant that served a "loaded" beer - chamoy in the beer itself, and the rim salted in tajin. And this type of beer beverage was the inspiration for my recipe.
Unfortunately, friends who've tasted this think that the tajin-salted rim is so intense that it distracts from the braggot (which they really enjoy by itself), and doesn't add anything. Adding chamoy to the braggot is seemed slightly less distracting to them, but again, it didn't add anything in their opinion.
So my pepper implementation - as entertaining of an idea as I still think it was - sounds like it might've been a miss. But on the bright side, I'm pleased that it's easy to serve without the tajin, because everyone who's given me feedback so far thinks the base braggot came out fantastic.
11/27/2021 - more tasting
Some out of town friends visited and tried the braggot today. I didn't bother having them try the tajin or chamoy, since the initial tasting very strongly did not favor those additions. But the base braggot again received a glowing review!
I'm a little disappointed I didn't get the pepper in more successfully, since that was part of the challenge. But at the end of the day I made 3 gallons of this, and if I'm being honest I'll going to end up serving it the way my friends enjoy it - after all, is that not why we homebrew? To share something enjoyable with our friends and family?
Flame out for the mash
Nothing of note yet